№ 167 · earth science

A snowflake gets six sides from its ice and six matching arms from its weather

A snowflake has six sides because the ice it is made of is built from hexagons. Its six arms match for a different reason. They do not copy each other. They grew at the same time, in the same patch of cloud, so they met the same weather.

The hexagon is in the ice

A water molecule is one oxygen atom with two hydrogen atoms attached. The two bonds meet at 104.5°, close to 109.5°, the angle between the corners of a tetrahedron. In ice each oxygen ends up with four bonds to its neighbours, two tight ones inside its own molecule and two weaker hydrogen bonds to the molecules next to it, pointing roughly to the corners of a tetrahedron. Kenneth Libbrecht's monograph on snow crystals explains that molecules held this way can stack in two ways. The ordinary one, called ice Ih, has hexagonal symmetry. Looked at straight down one axis, the crystal is a honeycomb of six-sided rings.

People asked why snow has six points long before anyone could see a molecule. Libbrecht credits the English astronomer Thomas Harriot with first recording the six-fold symmetry in Europe, in 1591. In 1611 Johannes Kepler wrote a short book on the six-cornered snowflake and guessed that it had something to do with how round things stack. He was on the right track. In 1929 William Barnes used X-rays to work out the arrangement of the molecules in ice and found the hexagonal lattice.

Why a hexagon and not a ball

A lattice sets which directions are special. It does not by itself say what shape a crystal grows into. Copper is a crystal too, and it seldom grows flat faces. Ice does, and the reason is how vapour sticks.

A snow crystal grows by taking water molecules straight from the vapour in the air. Molecules hit its surface everywhere. Where the surface is rough at the molecular scale, with plenty of loose bonds, they tend to stick. A facet, a flat face lined up with the lattice, has fewer loose bonds, so molecules that land on it are more likely to leave again. The rough patches fill in fast and the flat faces lag behind, so the slowest faces end up as the outside of the crystal. For ice those are two flat ends and six sides: a six-sided prism.

This is a shape made by growth, not the shape ice would settle into if left alone. In a 2023 paper Libbrecht and James Walkling argue that the evidence so far points to ice in vapour having almost no preference for flat faces at rest, at least above −15 °C. Left alone long enough, a small crystal there would round off to nearly a sphere. The hexagon comes from the difference in how fast the faces grow.

Temperature decides which faces grow slowest. Near −15 °C the two flat ends barely grow while the six sides take vapour readily, so the crystal becomes a thin six-sided plate. Near −5 °C it grows into columns and needles instead.

Interactive A toy snow crystal growing from one frozen speck. Pick the grid it grows on and the air around it. Every cell follows the same local rule: it takes in vapour from its neighbours and freezes once it holds enough. Under the picture, the figure turns its own crystal by 60° and by 90° and reports how much of the ice lands on ice. Every control works with Tab and Enter.

the grid (the crystal's built-in directions)
the air around the crystal
Growing…

From a plate to six arms

A small plate does not stay a plate. Its six corners stick out slightly into the damp air, so vapour reaches them a little faster than it reaches the middle of each side. The corners grow faster and stick out further, which brings them more vapour still. That runaway is a branching instability, and it is why a plate sprouts six arms, one from each corner. From then on most of the growth happens at the tips of the arms. In the figure, flip the grid to square: the same rule, with nothing else changed, grows four arms. The number of arms comes from the grid, not from the rule.

Predict first

A fancy snowflake has six arms covered in matching side branches. How do the arms end up matching?

Check your answer

The third. Libbrecht is explicit that the arms are not kept in step by any communication between them. Each arm reacts to the temperature and humidity around it, and all six travel together, so they get the same changes at the same times. Ice does not insist on a perfect copy, either: the commonest snow crystals are small and lopsided.

Why the arms match

How an arm grows is quite sensitive to the temperature and humidity right around it. A crystal falling through a cloud keeps passing through slightly different air. At one moment its arm tips grow flat faces; a little later they sprout side branches. The final shape of each arm is a record of the path the crystal took.

All six arms take that path together. They meet essentially the same air at the same times, so they share one history and grow the same pattern of branches. Libbrecht grows symmetric crystals in his lab this way, by changing the temperature and humidity in steps while one crystal grows; it took him about 45 minutes to grow the one he shows. The figure lets you try the same idea. With "Changing air, the same all round", the crystal grows bursts of side branches but stays symmetric, and turning it by 60° puts every ice cell onto ice. With "Patchy air", each side gets its own weather, and the arms stop matching.

That is also why no two snowflakes look the same. No two crystals follow exactly the same path through a turbulent cloud. (Libbrecht adds that the full story of snowflake uniqueness is a bit more involved than that.)

Most snowflakes are not like the pictures

The perfect stars in photographs are picked out. Libbrecht writes that almost every snowfall brings many small, malformed plate-like crystals he calls irregulars, and that clumps of them are far more common than the well-formed kinds. Crystals that run into cloud droplets get coated in frozen specks called rime. Even the symmetry can come out differently: in one of his lab runs near −10 °C, about one small plate in twenty grew as a blunt triangle, with long and short sides taking turns.

In short

Water molecules lock into a lattice of six-sided rings, so ice has six special directions. Flat faces lined up with the lattice take on vapour slowly, so a growing crystal becomes a six-sided prism or plate. Its corners stick out into the vapour and run ahead as six arms. The arms match because they grew side by side through the same changing air, not because they share any plan. Most real snowflakes get knocked about along the way and come out irregular.

Where this comes from

  1. Snow Crystals linked only, not reproduced
    Kenneth G. Libbrecht · arXiv:1910.06389 · 2019
    arxiv.org/abs/1910.06389
  2. A Comprehensive Model of Snow Crystal Faceting reuse permitted with attribution
    Kenneth G. Libbrecht and James Walkling · arXiv:2306.04042 · 2023
    arxiv.org/abs/2306.04042
  3. A local cellular model for snow crystal growth linked only, not reproduced
    Clifford A. Reiter · 2005
    doi.org/10.1016/j.chaos.2004.06.071