№ 138 · biology

Why are plants green, not black?

A leaf looks green because the pigments inside it take in blue and red light and let green pass through or bounce off. The question is why the pigments take in less green than red and blue, instead of soaking up everything and making the leaf look black. Clark, Douglas and Choi describe chlorophyll a as absorbing at both ends of the visible range but not in the middle, so the middle is what reaches your eye. Why the pigments leave that gap is still argued, and the sources offer more than one answer.

What a pigment does

A pigment is a molecule that absorbs some wavelengths and reflects or transmits the rest. Wavelength is the distance between wave crests, and shorter waves carry more energy. Clark, Douglas and Choi put the usable range for plants at 700 nm down to 400 nm, which they call photosynthetically active radiation. Light with less energy than red does not lift an electron into an excited state. Light with more energy than blue can break the molecule apart, a process they call bleaching.

Chlorophyll a and chlorophyll b give leaves their green. A carotenoid such as β-carotene absorbs blue and green and reflects yellow, orange and red. A leaf holding several pigments can harvest a wider band than one pigment alone.

Where the energy goes

In the thylakoid membrane, a photosystem pairs a light-harvesting complex with a reaction centre. The complex gathers several hundred chlorophyll a and b molecules, 300 to 400 of them, along with other pigments. A photon absorbed anywhere in that antenna excites a molecule, and the energy hops from chlorophyll to chlorophyll. After roughly a millionth of a second it reaches the reaction centre. Only energy moves up to this point, not electrons. There a pair of chlorophyll a molecules gives up an electron. In photosystem II, an electron taken from water replaces it.

Why not black?

Predict first

If a leaf absorbed every visible wavelength, it would look black and capture more light. Why does chlorophyll leave a gap in the green?

Check your answer

Battle, Vegliani and Jones report a suggestion that these absorbance troughs help prevent photodamage under strong light. Green light is not useless, though: once inside the leaf it drives photosynthesis efficiently.

Battle, Vegliani and Jones note that most of the sun's energy falls in the green region, yet the photosynthetic pigments absorb less there than in red and blue. They report the proposal that the troughs guard against photodamage when light is strong. They also report that green light absorbed by a leaf is highly efficient at driving photosynthesis, and that it matters more for carbon fixation in cells deeper inside the leaf, where much of the incoming light has already been absorbed or bounced away.

A tuning argument

Arp and colleagues offer a different account in a 2020 modelling study. They model the antenna as a network with two input channels and one output. Noise means fluctuation in the power arriving compared with the steady output the network needs. In their model, two peaks placed close together on a steeply sloping part of the sunlight spectrum keep the absorbed power close to that steady output, which is the condition they link to efficient conversion. Their model reproduces measured absorption peaks of green plants, purple bacteria and green sulfur bacteria with an average error of 2.1%. They report that the pigments do not sit at the point of maximum solar power. They also say the connection to real antennae needs detailed quantum models. It is one model checked against known spectra, not a measured test of why plants evolved this way.

Green is also a signal

Light tells a plant about its surroundings, not just how much energy is on offer. Battle, Vegliani and Jones point out that no photoreceptor dedicated to green light has been identified. Red and blue receptors respond to it instead. Phytochromes, which switch between a red-absorbing and a far-red-absorbing form, have broad spectra reaching into green. Cryptochromes, blue sensors, can hold an intermediate that absorbs green. The authors argue that responses to short-wave green and to longer yellow light should be treated as separate, and they say the mechanisms are still poorly understood.

Interactive Drag the slider to move a marker across the visible spectrum. The readout shows how much of the light this sketch of chlorophyll a absorbs at that wavelength. It is one pigment, not a whole leaf.

Absorption (solid) and the share not absorbed (dashed) against wavelength, for a sketch of chlorophyll a. The humps sit at 428 and 660 nm, the chlorophyll a peaks listed by Arp and colleagues; Clark, Douglas and Choi describe the pigment as taking in blue and red but not green. The marker follows the slider.

In short

Chlorophyll absorbs at the red and blue ends and lets green through, so the leaf looks green. Whether that gap is protection against too much light, a tuning choice for steady power, or both, the sources do not settle.

Where this comes from

  1. Quieting a noisy antenna reproduces photosynthetic light harvesting spectra linked only, not reproduced
    Arp, Kistner-Morris, Aji, Cogdell, van Grondelle, Gabor · 2020
    arxiv.org/abs/1912.12281
  2. Shades of green: untying the knots of green photoperception linked only, not reproduced
    Battle, Vegliani, Jones · 2020
    pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC7541914
  3. Biology 2e, 8.2 The Light-Dependent Reactions of Photosynthesis linked only, not reproduced
    Clark, Douglas, Choi · 2018
    openstax.org/books/biology-2e/pages/8-2-the-light-dependent-reactions-of-photosynthesis