Moon phases are not Earth's shadow
A common explanation of the Moon's phases is that Earth's shadow creeps across it, covering more of it, then less. It is wrong. Earth's shadow points straight away from the Sun, and a crescent Moon sits close to the Sun in the sky, nowhere near that shadow. The phases are something simpler: the Moon is a ball lit from one side, and as it goes round us we see different amounts of its sunlit half. Earth's shadow does reach the Moon now and then, and that is a lunar eclipse.
The shadow idea is everywhere. In a survey of 2,589 students in French-speaking Belgium made in the first half of 2012, Yael Naze and Sebastien Fontaine found that about 40% of the students who said the Moon's shape changes over a night or a month picked the Moon passing into Earth's shadow as the cause. The right answer, that the Moon goes round Earth, got 28% from those who said a night and 38% from those who said a month. Andrew Fraknoi, David Morrison and Sidney Wolff open their textbook section on the phases by noting that many people think the phases are somehow related to Earth's shadow.
Half lit, always
The Moon makes no light of its own. It shines by reflected sunlight, and like any ball in sunlight, half of it is lit and half is dark at every moment. What changes through the month is how much of that lit half is turned towards us, and that depends only on the angle between the Sun and the Moon as we see them.
At new Moon the Moon is in roughly the same direction as the Sun. Its lit half faces away from us, and we see its dark side, which gives off no light of its own. A day or two later the Moon has moved about 12° a day eastwards away from the Sun, and a thin edge of the lit half comes into view: a crescent, in the evening sky not far from where the Sun went down. At 90° from the Sun we see exactly half of the disc lit, first quarter, and the Moon rises around noon. At 180°, opposite the Sun, the whole lit half faces us: full Moon, rising at sunset and setting at sunrise. Then the same shapes come back in reverse. One full cycle of phases takes 29.53 days.
There is a neat rule behind the shapes. If the Moon is at an angle E from the Sun, the lit share of the disc is (1 − cos E) ÷ 2. At 45° that is about 15%, at 90° it is 50%, and at 135° about 85%. Nothing in that rule mentions Earth's shadow.
Where Earth's shadow actually points
Earth casts its shadow on the side away from the Sun, the night side. A crescent Moon is only a few tens of degrees from the Sun in our sky, so it is on the daytime side of Earth, and the shadow is pointing off in very nearly the opposite direction. The only time the Moon is out where the shadow goes is around full Moon.
Even at full Moon it usually misses. The Moon's orbit is tilted by about 5° to the plane of Earth's orbit, which is the plane the shadow lies in. Most months the full Moon passes a little north or south of the shadow. Espenak and Meeus find that a lunar eclipse needs the full Moon to fall within about 17° of one of the two points where the orbits cross, called nodes. In their 5,000-year canon, from 2000 BCE to 3000 CE, there are 12,064 lunar eclipses. Over the same span there are about 61,800 full Moons, by our arithmetic, so about one full Moon in five has any eclipse at all. More than a third of those eclipses only touch the faint outer shadow, the penumbra, which is hard to see at all. A total eclipse, with the whole Moon in the dark central shadow, comes at about one full Moon in eighteen, again by our arithmetic from their count of 3,479 total eclipses.
Interactive Drag hours after new Moon, or press Play, to take the Moon once round its orbit. On the left, the Sun is far off to the right and Earth's shadow points away from it. On the right is the Moon as you would see it. Choose a month: in most months the full Moon passes north or south of Earth's shadow; a few times a year it lines up. Every control works with Tab, Enter, Space and the arrow keys.
Waxing crescent: 17% of the disc we see is lit.
Left: the dotted line is your line of sight to the Moon. Right: grey-blue glow on the dark part is earthlight (brightness exaggerated); the dashed orange circle is the edge of Earth's dark central shadow when it is near.
4 days 0 hours after new Moon. Seen from Earth, the Moon is 48.9° from the Sun. Lit share of the disc = (1 − cos 48.9°) ÷ 2 = 17%.
Earth's shadow points straight away from the Sun. The Moon's centre is 131.1° from the middle of that shadow, and 4.1° south of the plane of Earth's orbit. It misses the Moon completely.
Seen from the Moon, Earth would be 83% lit. That earthlight is the faint glow on the Moon's dark part.
Two shapes that give the game away
The line between the bright and dark parts of the Moon, called the terminator, is the edge of the sunlit half of a ball. Seen from far away, that edge is always half of an ellipse whose two ends sit at opposite ends of a diameter of the disc. That is why the horns of a crescent always point straight away from each other across the Moon, and why a crescent's inner edge curves the same way as its outer edge.
A real eclipse looks different. Espenak and Meeus describe Earth's dark central shadow as usually about 2.7 times as wide as the Moon, so during a partial eclipse it looks as if a round bite has been taken out of the Moon. The edge of that bite is an arc of a much bigger circle, and its ends do not have to sit across a diameter. Aristotle used that curved edge to argue that Earth is round, because its shadow was round at every eclipse, wherever the Moon was in the sky. And during totality the Moon does not go black. Earth's atmosphere bends some sunlight into the shadow and scatters away the blue, so a totally eclipsed Moon usually turns a dim orange or red, and now and then dark brown or grey.
The shapes trip people up as well. In a recent survey of more than 2,000 secondary school students across India, Moupiya Maji and 30 colleagues showed drawings of the Moon and asked which one it looks like two days after new Moon. Only 25% chose the right drawing, a thin crescent. The most popular choice, picked by 37%, had a straight edge between light and dark. The authors note that some of the popular choices suggest a picture of the phases like an eclipse.
The glow in the dark part
Look at a thin crescent on a clear evening and you can often see the rest of the disc glowing faintly. That light is earthshine. Peter Thejll and colleagues describe the Moon's dark side as almost always lit by some of the sunlit Earth. E. Palle and colleagues credit the explanation to Leonardo da Vinci, around 1510: sunlight bounces off the daytime Earth onto the Moon's dark part and back to us. Astronomers have used that glow to measure how much sunlight Earth reflects, and Palle's team followed it from 1998 to 2014.
Earthshine settles the question on its own. When we see a thin crescent, an astronaut on the Moon would see an almost full Earth, so the dark part of a crescent is lit by bright earthlight, as the figure shows. If that dark part were in Earth's shadow, it would be the one part of the Moon that Earth could not light.
In short
Half of the Moon is always lit by the Sun. The phases are how much of that lit half faces us, set by the angle between the Sun and the Moon in our sky. Earth's shadow points away from the Sun, so it can only reach a full Moon, and because the Moon's orbit is tilted it usually misses. When it does not miss, the result is a lunar eclipse, which looks nothing like a phase.
Where this comes from
- An astronomical survey conducted in Belgium linked only, not reproduced
arxiv.org/abs/1308.3963 - Status of Astronomy Education in India: A Baseline Survey linked only, not reproduced
arxiv.org/abs/2406.12308 - On the colour of the dark side of the Moon linked only, not reproduced
arxiv.org/abs/1401.1994 - Earth's albedo variations 1998-2014 as measured from ground-based earthshine observations linked only, not reproduced
arxiv.org/abs/1604.05880 - Astronomy 2e, §4.5 Phases and Motions of the Moon linked only, not reproduced
openstax.org/books/astronomy-2e/pages/4-5-phases-and-motions-of-the-moon - Five Millennium Canon of Lunar Eclipses: -1999 to +3000 (NASA/TP-2009-214172) linked only, not reproduced
eclipse.gsfc.nasa.gov/5MCLE/5MCLE-Text10.pdf - Moon Fact Sheet linked only, not reproduced
nssdc.gsfc.nasa.gov/planetary/factsheet/moonfact.html - Earth Fact Sheet linked only, not reproduced
nssdc.gsfc.nasa.gov/planetary/factsheet/earthfact.html - Sun Fact Sheet linked only, not reproduced
nssdc.gsfc.nasa.gov/planetary/factsheet/sunfact.html