№ 150 · biology

What a hollow shaft does to bending resistance

A long bone is not a solid rod. Its middle is a tube: a wall of dense compact bone around a hollow space called the medullary cavity, which holds yellow marrow. None of the three sources says long bones became hollow in order to be stiffer. This page looks only at what hollowing does to bending resistance.

What is inside a long bone

Betts and colleagues describe the parts. The diaphysis is the shaft between the two ends, and its walls are compact bone. The hollow inside it is the medullary cavity. Each wider end, the epiphysis, is filled with spongy bone, whose spaces hold red marrow. The endosteum lines the cavity, and the periosteum wraps the outside.

The same source notes that spongy bone's open spaces make bones lighter, so muscles can move them more easily. That passage is about spongy bone; the source gives no reason for the hollow shaft.

Bending resistance is a shape property

Huie, Summers and Kawano define the second moment of area as a measure of how well a cross-section resists bending because of its shape. In beam theory the deflection of a loaded beam depends on the length cubed, the force, the inverse of the material's elastic modulus, and the inverse of this second moment of area. When the bones compared share one material, Huie and colleagues say differences in bending resistance come down to the second moment of area.

They list three ways to raise it: a bigger cross-section, more material in the section, or material moved away from the centre toward the direction of loading.

Where the material sits

Baker and Haynes show how the pieces add up. A composite shape's moment of inertia is the sum of its parts' moments about one common axis, with holes subtracted. A part whose centroid is off that axis contributes its own value plus its area times the square of its distance from the axis. That squared distance is why far-out material counts heavily.

Their beam example makes it concrete. Three 2×6 planks nailed side by side, each standing on its narrow edge, give 62.4 in4; rearranged into an I-shape, the same planks give 226 in4, a ratio of 3.61. They call this optimisation of material usage the reason I-beams are used.

Predict first

Same amount of bone, same length. Which shaft resists bending more: a solid rod, or a hollow tube with the bone moved out to the wall?

Check your answer

The hollow tube. Second moment of area rises when material is moved away from the centre toward the loading direction, so the same bone arranged as a wall beats the same bone packed into a core.

Interactive Slide to set the inner radius as a fraction of the outer radius; the cross-sectional area stays fixed, so the ring widens and its wall thins.

Left: the cross-section, every position drawn at one scale. The shaded ring has the same area at every slider position; the dashed circle is a solid rod of that area. Right: second moment of area about a diameter, in units of the solid rod's radius to the fourth power; the dashed line is the solid rod. The slider range is illustrative, not taken from measured bones.

Why the hollow wins

Take a fixed amount of material and spread it into a ring. As the ring's radius grows, its wall thins to keep the area constant, but the material moves outward. Because each element's contribution grows with the square of its distance from the centre, the total climbs. A solid rod of the same area keeps its material closer to the middle.

Huie and colleagues use a related comparison: dividing a structure's second moment by that of a solid circle of the same cross-sectional area gives a ratio for how well the material is arranged. For the midshaft of a salamander humerus, they report that the bone's mineral is laid out to resist dorsoventral loads 2.2 times better than the same area formed into a solid circle.

What the model leaves out, and what is unsettled

Baker and Haynes note that the web of an I-beam mainly carries shear and holds the flanges apart, while the flanges, furthest from the neutral axis, take most of the tension and compression.

Beam theory also has conditions. Huie and colleagues say deflections should stay under about 10% of length, and that a length at least ten times the thickness helps make shear a negligible part of the deflection. Some long thin bones, such as bat phalanges and bird hyoids, deform far more than the small-deflection limit. They also note that bone is viscoelastic, so a static calculation may fail to describe a moving animal.

Huie and colleagues (2022) also list limits of their own tool. It measures about axes through the centroid, but the neutral axis of a weight-bearing bone loaded at its end does not pass through the centroid. Density-weighted measurements need calibrated CT scans, which most scans in online repositories are not. And the 2022 version offers no method to account for cross-section size.

In short

A long bone's shaft is a tube of compact bone around marrow. Bending resistance depends on how far the material sits from the neutral axis, and a wall placed outward beats a solid core of the same amount of bone. Betts and colleagues say the cavity holds yellow marrow; the sources do not say why the shaft is hollow.

Where this comes from

  1. Anatomy and Physiology 2e, 6.3 Bone Structure (OpenStax) linked only, not reproduced
    Betts, Young, Wise, Johnson, Poe, Kruse, Korol, Johnson, Womble, DeSaix · 2022
    openstax.org/books/anatomy-and-physiology-2e/pages/6-3-bone-structure
  2. SegmentGeometry: A Tool for Measuring Second Moment of Area in 3D Slicer (Integrative Organismal Biology 4:obac009) linked only, not reproduced
    Huie, Summers, Kawano · 2022
    pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC8919404/
  3. Engineering Statics: Open and Interactive, 10.4 Moment of Inertia of Composite Shapes linked only, not reproduced
    Baker, Haynes · 2026
    engineeringstatics.org/Chapter_10-moment-of-inertia-of-composite-shapes.html