№ 143 · biology

Fever is a changed setting, not the illness

A fever is not the illness. It is a change in the temperature your body is aiming for. The hypothalamus, a small region at the base of the brain, holds a target core temperature, and fever means that target has been raised. The surprise is that this shift is often useful: Walter and colleagues note that fever during sepsis can come with better survival, while the same rise from non-infective causes does not.

What a fever is

Walter, Hanna-Jumma, Carraretto and Forni describe the chain. Exogenous pyrogens such as micro-organisms, or endogenous pyrogens such as interleukin-1, interleukin-6 and tumour necrosis factor, reach the organum vasculosum of the lamina terminalis (OVLT), a small structure in the anterior hypothalamus that lacks a blood–brain barrier. Stimulation there raises production of prostaglandin E2, which acts in the pre-optic nucleus and slows the firing of warm-sensitive neurons. The result is a higher body temperature.

Evans, Repasky and Fisher give the same axis more detail. Interleukin-6 is needed to sustain fever: in their account, mice lacking it, or given an antibody against it, do not develop fever after lipopolysaccharide, a component of bacterial cell walls. Prostaglandin E2 then binds EP3 receptors on thermoregulatory neurons in the median preoptic nucleus. The body raises its temperature by releasing norepinephrine, which increases heat production in brown adipose tissue, and by narrowing blood vessels in the extremities so less heat escapes.

Two different things

Walter and colleagues point out that the terms are not settled. Some definitions call any core temperature of 38.3 °C or above a fever, whatever the cause. Others reserve “fever” for a rise driven by pyrogens acting on the hypothalamus, and use hyperthermia for heat gained from outside or from heat production that outruns heat loss, as in heatstroke or drug reactions. The NHS, as of 2023, tells adults that 38 °C or above is usually a high temperature, and adds that feeling hot, cold or shivery matters even when a thermometer reads lower.

Predict first

In the lipopolysaccharide model Evans and colleagues describe, what happens to the fever if the prostaglandin E2 step is missing?

Check your answer

The second. Evans and colleagues report that, in the lipopolysaccharide model, interleukin-6 cannot start a fever without cyclooxygenase 2 or prostaglandin E2, and that injecting prostaglandin E2 into the brain restores fever in mice that lack interleukin-6. Walter and colleagues add that ceramide may act as a messenger independent of prostaglandin E2, so the complete block in the figure is a simplification.

Why the shift may help

Evans and colleagues note that a 1 °C rise costs a 10–12.5% increase in metabolic rate, and that the response has been kept across vertebrates for a very long time. In their account, experiments that hold cells or animals at febrile-range temperatures of 38–41 °C boost several immune steps: more neutrophils are recruited to infected sites, dendritic cells move to lymph nodes and stimulate T cells better, and lymphocytes bind more firmly to the vessel walls of lymph nodes. Interleukin-6 drives that last step through a mechanism called trans-signalling, in which the cytokine pairs with a soluble receptor. They also describe a study in rabbits infected with rinderpest virus: 70% of animals given aspirin died, against 16% of those with a normal febrile response.

Walter and colleagues report that, in infected intensive-care patients, a raised temperature in the first 24 hours was linked to better outcomes than normothermia, and that elderly patients with pneumonia who did not develop fever had higher mortality (29%) than those who did (4%).

Where it turns harmful

Both reviews say the benefit has limits. Walter and colleagues report that mortality rises again above about 40 °C, and that in intensive-care patients whose raised temperature was not driven by pyrogens, 37.5 °C or more trended towards a worse outcome, becoming significant above 38.5 °C. In their account of hyperthermia, they describe direct cell death around 41 °C, reduced gut barrier function, and falling glomerular filtration as temperature climbs. Evans and colleagues note that uncontrolled fever is linked to worse outcomes in sepsis and neurological injury, and that antipyretics also act on parts of inflammation besides temperature, which makes the value of fever hard to measure.

Interactive Move the pyrogen slider to add inflammatory signal, then press block PGE2 to see what happens when the prostaglandin step is switched off.

Left: the pathway as a chain of boxes, each with a bar for signal strength. Right: core temperature against pyrogen level. The dashed line is 38 °C, the NHS threshold for adults (NHS, 2023); the dotted line is 40 °C, above which Walter and colleagues report mortality rising again; the shaded band runs from 38 to 41 °C, the febrile range Evans and colleagues describe. The curve and the bar lengths are illustrative: the curve rises from 37 °C at zero pyrogen to 41 °C at full pyrogen, and neither is a measurement.

In short

Fever is a raised target, set by pyrogens acting through prostaglandin E2 on the hypothalamus. The heat that follows can help the immune response, but above roughly 40 °C, or when the cause is not infection, the same rise is linked to harm.

Where this comes from

  1. The pathophysiological basis and consequences of fever (Crit. Care 20:200) linked only, not reproduced
    Walter, Hanna-Jumma, Carraretto, Forni · 2016
    pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC4944485/
  2. Fever and the thermal regulation of immunity: the immune system feels the heat (Nat. Rev. Immunol. 15:335) linked only, not reproduced
    Evans, Repasky, Fisher · 2015
    pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC4786079/
  3. High temperature (fever) in adults linked only, not reproduced
    NHS · 2023
    www.nhs.uk/symptoms/fever-in-adults/