An eclipse is a shadow with a size
A solar eclipse is the Moon's shadow falling on Earth. That shadow is not a vague dimming. It has a shape and a size you can work out from three numbers: how big the Sun and Moon are, and how far apart everything is. The dark core of the Moon's shadow is a cone that is almost exactly as long as the distance from the Moon to Earth. Whether its tip touches the ground or stops short decides what kind of eclipse you get, and its width decides who gets to see it.
Two shadows, one inside the other
The Sun is not a point of light. It is a disc, so anything that blocks it casts two shadows. In the inner one, the umbra, the whole Sun is hidden. Around it lies the penumbra, where only part of the Sun is hidden. Stand in the penumbra and you see a partial eclipse. Stand in the umbra and you see a total one.
The umbra cannot go on forever. The Sun is much bigger than the Moon, so the edges of the Moon's dark shadow lean inward and meet at a point, like a cone. Espenak and Meeus describe what lies past that point: the cone's sides cross and spread out again into a second, widening cone called the antumbra. Inside it the Moon looks smaller than the Sun, so it sits in the middle of the Sun's disc as a black circle with a bright ring around it. That is an annular eclipse.
How long is the Moon's shadow?
The length of the cone follows from similar triangles. NASA's fact sheets, kept by David Williams, give the Sun's mean radius as 695,700 km and the Moon's as 1,737.4 km, so the Sun is about 400 times wider. The cone therefore narrows from the Moon's full width to nothing over roughly 1/400 of the distance from the Moon to the Sun. With Earth at its average distance from the Sun, 149.6 million km, that comes to about 373,600 km.
Now compare that with the Moon's distance. The fact sheet gives the Moon's distance from Earth's centre as roughly 357,000 km at its nearest and 407,000 km at its farthest, 384,400 km on average. The ground under the Moon is another 6,371 km closer, one Earth radius. At its nearest, the Moon puts the ground about 350,600 km away, and the 373,600 km cone reaches it with room to spare: the eclipse is total. At its average distance, the ground is about 378,000 km away, and the tip falls about 4,500 km short: the eclipse is annular. The cone's length and the Moon's distance are so close that small changes in either one flip the result.
Earth's distance from the Sun matters too. Earth is nearest the Sun, 147.1 million km away, in early January and farthest, 152.1 million km, in early July. A farther Sun makes the cone longer. Espenak and Meeus find exactly the pattern this predicts. Total eclipses are nearly 1½ times as likely in May, June and July as in November, December and January. Annular eclipses are 1⅓ times as likely in November to January as in May to July.
Interactive The Moon's shadow at a solar eclipse, worked out from the sizes and distances of the Sun, Moon and Earth. Pick how far Earth is from the Sun and set how far the Moon is from Earth. The top strip shows how long the Moon's dark shadow cone is and whether its tip reaches the ground. Bottom left: the Sun and Moon as seen from the ground straight under the Moon. Bottom right: Earth's own shadow where the Moon would cross it at a lunar eclipse, with the Moon at the same distance. Every control works with Tab, Enter and the arrow keys.
Annular: a ring of Sun stays visible
Total in the middle, a ring at the ends
Earth is round, so its surface is not all the same distance from the Moon. The middle of the eclipse track faces the Moon and is closest to it, up to one Earth radius closer than the places near Earth's edge, where the shadow arrives at sunrise or sunset. When the cone's tip falls in between, the eclipse is total along the middle of its track and annular near both ends. Espenak and Meeus count 569 of these hybrid eclipses in their 5,000 years. In 519 of them the path starts as a ring, turns total, and goes back to a ring.
A shadow a few hundred kilometres wide
Where the cone's tip passes the ground, the dark spot is the cone's width at that point, so it is never large. Working it out from the fact-sheet numbers, the widest it gets is when the Moon is nearest and Earth is farthest from the Sun: about 270 km across. The penumbra, in contrast, is about 7,000 km across. That is why a partial eclipse can be seen from much of a continent while totality is a narrow track that people travel to reach. Espenak and Meeus note that the penumbra's region often covers more than half of Earth's daylit side.
Because the spot is small and the Moon moves fast, totality is short. The longest total eclipse in the NASA canon, on 16 July 2186, lasts 7 minutes 29 seconds, close to the theoretical maximum of 7 minutes 32 seconds for that era. It falls, as the cone's length predicts, in July, when Earth is farthest from the Sun. Annular eclipses can last longer: ten in the canon last 12 minutes or more on the centre line.
Why not every month?
The Moon passes between Earth and the Sun at every new Moon, about once every 29.5 days. But its orbit is tilted by about 5° to the plane of Earth's orbit, 5.145° in the fact sheet. Most months the shadow passes above or below Earth and misses it altogether. An eclipse can only happen when new Moon falls close to one of the two places where the Moon's orbit crosses that plane. Espenak and Meeus find between two and five solar eclipses in every calendar year, and 72.5% of years have just two.
Earth's shadow is far bigger
A lunar eclipse is the same geometry turned around: the Moon passes through Earth's shadow. Earth is about 3.7 times wider than the Moon, so its dark cone is much longer, about 1.38 million km by the same arithmetic. At the Moon's average distance it is still about 9,200 km wide, about 2.65 times the Moon's own width. The whole Moon fits inside with room to move, so a total lunar eclipse lasts far longer than a total solar eclipse. Espenak and Meeus's lunar canon lists 18 total lunar eclipses of 106 minutes or more in its 5,000 years. The most recent was on 16 July 2000, and the next will be on 9 June 2123. Like the longest solar eclipses, they happen near the time of year when Earth is farthest from the Sun, when its shadow is largest.
Two things differ from the bare geometry. The Moon does not go black in Earth's shadow. The only light reaching it has been filtered through Earth's atmosphere, so it turns orange, deep red, brown or very dark grey. And the measured shadow is a little bigger than the geometry says. In the early 1700s Philippe de La Hire found the shadow had to be enlarged to match observed timings, and many national institutes enlarge it by 1/50 in their predictions. Espenak and Meeus explain it with Earth's air: the edge of the dark shadow behaves as if Earth were larger by a layer of atmosphere about 120 to 150 km high.
The shadow and the slowly drifting Moon
The Moon is moving away from Earth by about 3.8 cm a year, the rate in NASA's current Moon fact sheet. Espenak and Meeus describe how it is measured: by timing laser pulses bounced off reflectors the Apollo astronauts left on the Moon. That slowly moves the ground away from the shadow's tip. The margin is large. With the Moon at its nearest, the tip reaches about 17,000 to 29,000 km past the ground, depending on the season. At 3.8 cm a year, closing the smaller gap, about 16,800 km, would take about 440 million years. That is arithmetic at today's rate, not a forecast.
In short
The Moon's dark shadow is a cone about 373,600 km long, almost exactly the Moon's distance from Earth. When the Moon is near, the tip reaches the ground and the eclipse is total along a track at most a few hundred kilometres wide. When the Moon is far, the tip falls short and a ring of Sun stays visible. On average the Moon is slightly too far, which is why ring eclipses are more common than total ones. Earth's shadow is much bigger, so a total lunar eclipse can last well over an hour and a half, and anyone with the Moon above the horizon can see it.
Where this comes from
- Five Millennium Canon of Solar Eclipses: -1999 to +3000 (NASA/TP-2006-214141) linked only, not reproduced
eclipse.gsfc.nasa.gov/5MCSE/5MCSE-Text11.pdf - Five Millennium Canon of Lunar Eclipses: -1999 to +3000 (NASA/TP-2009-214172) linked only, not reproduced
eclipse.gsfc.nasa.gov/5MCLE/5MCLE-Text10.pdf - Moon Fact Sheet linked only, not reproduced
nssdc.gsfc.nasa.gov/planetary/factsheet/moonfact.html - Sun Fact Sheet linked only, not reproduced
nssdc.gsfc.nasa.gov/planetary/factsheet/sunfact.html - Earth Fact Sheet linked only, not reproduced
nssdc.gsfc.nasa.gov/planetary/factsheet/earthfact.html