№ 137 · biology

How does DNA copy itself, and why is an error not always a disease?

Before a cell divides, it must copy its DNA. In the bacterium E. coli, the whole chromosome — 4.6 million base pairs — is copied in roughly 42 minutes by two replication forks working in opposite directions, each adding about 1000 nucleotides a second. The surprise is not the speed. It is that most copying errors are caught and fixed, and that a variant in your DNA is usually harmless.

How the copy is made

Clark, Douglas and Choi describe the machinery. An enzyme called helicase opens the double helix at a start site, the origin of replication, by breaking the bonds between base pairs. The opening forms Y-shaped replication forks, and two of them grow outward in both directions around the circle.

The builder is DNA polymerase. It reads one strand as a template and adds matching nucleotides one at a time. It can only add in one direction, 5′ to 3′, and it needs a free 3′-OH end to attach to. So RNA primase first lays down a short RNA primer of about five to ten nucleotides. DNA polymerase extends from there.

Because the two template strands run in opposite directions, one new strand, the leading strand, grows continuously. The other, the lagging strand, is built in short pieces called Okazaki fragments, each needing its own primer. DNA pol I later swaps the RNA primers for DNA, and ligase seals the remaining nicks.

Proofreading and repair

Clark, Douglas and Choi report that most replication mistakes are corrected right away by the polymerase itself. Before adding the next base, it checks whether the last one paired correctly. If not, it cuts the bond and releases the wrong nucleotide.

Errors that slip past this step can be fixed after replication by mismatch repair. Repair enzymes find the mispaired base and cut out part of the strand holding it, and the gap is rebuilt. In E. coli, the parental strand carries methyl groups that the new strand lacks, which tells the enzymes which copy to correct. In eukaryotes, the authors note, this mechanism is not well understood.

Predict first

A copying error reaches a skin cell and is never repaired. What happens to that person's children?

Check your answer

They do not inherit it. Clark, Douglas and Choi say mutations in germ cells are passed to the next generation; a skin cell is a somatic cell, where accumulated mutations can instead lead to problems such as cancer.

Why an error is not always a disease

Some errors change nothing. In a silent mutation, one base is swapped but the codon still spells the same amino acid, so the protein is unchanged; the authors say this usually happens at a codon's third position. Others swap one amino acid for another, which may or may not alter how the protein works.

Most variation in human genomes is harmless. The National Human Genome Research Institute states, as of 2023, that most genomic variants have no influence on how a genome functions, and that only a small fraction affects health. Some variants shape traits such as eye colour or height; a few directly cause diseases such as cystic fibrosis or sickle cell disease, while others only add to risk in conditions such as hypertension and diabetes.

When repair itself fails

Sometimes the fault lies in the repair tools. People with xeroderma pigmentosa carry defective nucleotide excision repair enzymes, the system that removes damage from UV light. Thymine dimers form and are not excised, and the authors say these people may face a higher risk of skin cancer. Faulty repair genes have also been tied to some pancreatic, colon and colorectal cancers.

Interactive Set how many bases are copied and how often the polymerase slips. Then switch proofreading and repair on or off and watch the errors that survive. The bases slider changes the counts in the readout; the bars stay per million.

Bars show errors per million bases copied, on a log scale: each faint line is a tenfold step. Proofreading and repair each remove a fixed share of the errors present; the shares are illustrative values, not measured rates. The surviving bar is what would become a mutation if left alone.

In short

Copying is fast and directional, proofreading catches most slips, and repair handles many of the rest. A surviving change may do nothing at all, and only a small share of variants matter for health.

Where this comes from

  1. Biology 2e, 14.4 DNA Replication in Prokaryotes linked only, not reproduced
    Clark, Douglas, Choi · 2018
    openstax.org/books/biology-2e/pages/14-4-dna-replication-in-prokaryotes
  2. Biology 2e, 14.6 DNA Repair linked only, not reproduced
    Clark, Douglas, Choi · 2018
    openstax.org/books/biology-2e/pages/14-6-dna-repair
  3. Human Genomic Variation (fact sheet) linked only, not reproduced
    National Human Genome Research Institute · 2023
    www.genome.gov/about-genomics/educational-resources/fact-sheets/human-genomic-variation