№ 133 · cosmology

What has been measured about dark matter, and what has not?

Dark matter is the name for whatever makes up most of the matter in the universe but gives off no light. Baudis and Profumo, writing the Particle Data Group's 2025 review, put it at 84.4% of the total matter density in their benchmark cosmology. The surprise is how much is pinned down about its gravity and how little about the particle itself: they say the makeup of the large majority is, as of 2025, unknown.

What has been measured

Dark matter is inferred from how mass moves. Baudis and Profumo list the tracers: stellar velocity dispersion, rotation curves, the virial theorem, gravitational lensing, and counts of stars and gas to subtract the ordinary matter. The same review says the effect shows up from the smallest galaxies up to clusters, and that the mass-to-light ratio levels off at the largest scales near the cosmological value.

The total amount is also measured, by cosmology rather than by any detector. In the benchmark model the review cites, dark matter is 26.4% of the critical density. Only a small slice is identified: the three Standard Model neutrinos account for somewhere between 0.5% and 1.6% of the non-baryonic matter.

What has been ruled out

Limits are measurements too, in the sense that they close off possibilities. Direct detection experiments look for a dark matter particle scattering off a nucleus in a detector. The review's table gives the tightest spin-independent limit as 2.2 × 10−48 cm2 at a mass of 40 GeV, from LUX-ZEPLIN.

Other properties are bounded. If dark matter particles scatter off each other, the cross section divided by mass must be below 0.47 cm2/g. If the particle carries a tiny electric charge, that charge must be below about 4 × 10−7 of the electron charge for a particle near 1 GeV, and the cap loosens as the mass grows. A single point-like constituent making up all the dark matter must be lighter than about 5 solar masses.

Predict first

Has any experiment yet detected a dark matter particle scattering in a detector?

Check your answer

No confirmed detection. Baudis and Profumo report that no signal has been seen at the LHC, and direct detection results are quoted as upper limits on cross sections. One experiment, DAMA/LIBRA, reports an annually modulated rate, but other experiments do not confirm it.

The one contested signal

DAMA/LIBRA, a sodium iodide experiment, reports an annually modulated event rate at 12.9σ over 20 annual cycles. A dark matter signal should modulate once a year, because the Earth's motion through the galaxy changes. But ANAIS finds its data incompatible with that modulation at 4σ, and COSINE-100 disfavors it as a WIMP signal, fully excluding the regions DAMA/LIBRA's result allows at 3σ. The review presents the modulation as reported but not confirmed.

What is still open

The particle's identity is unresolved. The review walks through candidates: WIMPs, axions, sterile neutrinos, dark photons, hidden sectors, and primordial black holes. Each has limits but no confirmed signal. The local density of dark matter near the Sun is also uncertain: global methods give 0.2–0.6 GeV/cm3, Gaia-based studies 0.3–1.5, and one 2025 machine-learning analysis gives 0.47 ± 0.05.

At small scales, simulations and observations disagree. The review names the missing satellites, cusp-core and too-big-to-fail problems, and says the likeliest fixes are ordinary baryonic physics, though new dark matter physics is also possible. It also notes that progress in both observing and modelling dwarf galaxies now leaves very scant evidence for a missing satellites problem.

Interactive Pick an experiment to see its spin-independent limit, then drag the slider to compare a hypothetical cross section against it.

Each bar is the tightest spin-independent limit at high mass quoted in Baudis and Profumo's Table 27.1, plotted as log10 of the cross section in cm2. A shorter bar means a stricter limit. The marker is the cross section you set. If it lands past the end of a bar, that experiment has excluded that value at the quoted mass; if it lands inside the bar, that experiment has not.

In short

Gravity tells us dark matter is there and how much of it there is. Detectors have pushed limits down hard but found nothing confirmed. What the particle is, and how it is distributed locally, remain open as of 2025.

Where this comes from

  1. 27. Dark Matter, Review of Particle Physics linked only, not reproduced
    Baudis, Profumo (Particle Data Group) · 2025
    ccwww.kek.jp/pdg/2025/reviews/rpp2025-rev-dark-matter.pdf